CO129-002 - Sir Henry Pottinger - 1843 — Page 251

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

249

details

because I think that the very points into which Major Aldrich has entered, serve to show that those views are correct. I must also beg to add,

that although, as a purely Military defensive measure, I admitted in my letter N. 3, of the 4th Instant, that Major Aldrich's plan had its advantages, I by no means intended, by that expression, to say that even in that light, I thought it, or do think it, the best that might be devised.

There are many parts of Major Aldrich's Report from which I totally differ; but even a minute examination of it, I have at this moment far more important and pressing calls on my attention. I shall, therefore, simply observe, that, I conceive Major Aldrich to be perfectly right in supporting his own opinions and plans by every argument and proof that may be within his power, yet, I cannot consider him justified in either assuming or adducing the sentiments of others.- I observe that in two places he distinctly states, that I do not consider internal defence to be requisite.. Had he said possible, I should perhaps have coincided with him "but, as that is a question on which I have not had occasion, except in a very cursory manner, to state my opinion, I cannot allow myself to

Edit History

2026-05-16 08:47:40 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
249 details because I think that the very points into which Major Aldrich has entered, serve to show that those views are correct. I must also beg to add, that although, as a purely Military defensive measure, I admitted in my letter N. 3, of the 4th Instant, that Major Aldrich's plan had its advantages, I by no means intended, by that expression, to say that even in that light, I thought it, or do think it, the best that might be devised. There are many parts of Major Aldrich's Report from which I totally differ; but even a minute examination of it, I have at this moment far more important and pressing calls on my attention. I shall, therefore, simply observe, that, I conceive Major Aldrich to be perfectly right in supporting his own opinions and plans by every argument and proof that may be within his power, yet, I cannot consider him justified in either assuming or adducing the sentiments of others.- I observe that in two places he distinctly states, that I do not consider internal defence to be requisite.. Had he said possible, I should perhaps have coincided with him "but, as that is a question on which I have not had occasion, except in a very cursory manner, to state my opinion, I cannot allow myself to
Baseline (Original)
249 details because I think that the very into which Major Aldrich has entered, serve to show that those views are correct ._ I must also beg to add, that although, Rs a purely Military defensive measure, I admitted in my letter N. 3, of the 4th Instant, that plans had its advantages, Aldrick's plan Major yet, I by ded, by that expression, to say that even in that light, I thought it, or do think it ; the best that might be devided. no means intended, There are many parts of Major which I totally it my Aldrick's Report from differ; but even province to into were A minute examination of it, I have at this moment for more important and my attention. and pressing calls on I shall, therefore, simply observe, that, I conceive Major althougsh Aldrich to b perfectly right in supporting his own opinions and plans by every argument_ and proof that power, yet, may be within this I cannot consider him "justified in either assuming or adducing the sentiments. f others.- I observe any that in two places the distinctly states, that I do not consider internal defence to be requisite.. Had he said possible, I should perhaps have coincided with him "but, as that is a question on which I have not hadi occasion, except in L very cursory manner, to state my opinion, I cannot allow myself to
2026-05-16 08:47:40 · Baseline
View content

249

details

because I think that the very into which Major Aldrich has entered, serve to show that those views are correct ._ I must also beg to add,

that although,

Rs a

purely Military

defensive measure, I admitted in my letter N. 3, of the 4th Instant, that

plans had its advantages,

Aldrick's plan

Major yet, I by

ded, by that expression, to say that even in that light, I thought it, or do think it ; the best that might be devided.

no means intended,

There

are

many parts of Major which I totally

it my

Aldrick's Report from differ; but even province to

into

were

A

minute

examination of it, I have at this moment for more

important

and

my

attention.

and pressing calls on I shall, therefore, simply observe, that,

I conceive Major

althougsh

Aldrich to b

perfectly right in supporting

his

own

opinions and plans by every argument_

and proof that

power, yet,

may

be within this I cannot consider him

"justified in either assuming or adducing

the sentiments.

f

others.- I observe

any

that in two places the distinctly states, that I do not consider internal defence to be requisite.. Had he said possible, I should perhaps have coincided with him "but, as that is a question

on

which

I have not hadi occasion, except

in

L

very cursory manner, to state my opinion, I cannot allow myself

to

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.